Peer-reviewed Articles

Please use the archived list on the right to look at past peer-reviewed articles.

2002

Du Toit,R., Pritchard,N., Heffernan,S., Simpson,T., Fonn,D. A comparison of three different scales for rating contact lens handling. Optometry and Vision Science 2002;79,5:313-320. [ Show Abstract ]

Purpose. To compare the validity, responsiveness, and reliability of three subjective rating scales applied to soft contact lens (SCL) handling. Methods. Fifty-four adapted SCL wearers handled three different types of lenses on two occasions and rated the handling with each scale: visual analogue scales (VAS), 20-interval visual analogue scales with descriptors (VAD) and Likert rating scales with five intervals (LRS). Results. There were significant differences between the scales (p < 0.01) and between the subjective ratings of lens handling (p < 0.001). VAS showed the least variability, exhibited the highest construct validity, were the most responsive, and were the most reliable: interclass correlations (0.63), coefficient of repeatability (27.5), and correlation between test and retest (Spearman r = 0.65, [all p < 0.05]). Higher repeatability, because of the fewer intervals of LRS, was not demonstrated and, generally, LRS was the least satisfactory scale. Handling was rated as easiest using VAD and most difficult using LRS. Conclusions. Although all three scales can be used to provide measures of lens handling, VAS may provide a simple and repeatable tool for measuring subjective responses.

Dumbleton,K. A., Chalmers,R. L., McNally,J., Bayer,S., Fonn,D. Effect of lens base curve on subjective comfort and assessment of fit with silicone hydrogel continuous wear contact lenses. Optometry and Vision Science 2002;79,10:633-637. [ Show Abstract ]

Purpose. To study the effect of base curve on subjective comfort of silicone hydrogel extended wear lenses. Methods. Ninety-five subjects were first trial fitted with 8.6-mm base curve lotrafilcon A (Focus Night & Day) lenses and then with 8.4-mm lenses only if poor subjective comfort or poor fit was present. Comfort and fit were assessed after 15 min. Subjects with discomfort or signs of poor fit were then trial fitted with 8.4-mm lenses. Results. Of 190 eyes, 74.2% were fitted with 8.6-mm lenses, and 23.7% required 8.4-mm lenses. Two (2.1%) subjects could not be fitted with either base curve. Mean steep keratometry (K) reading for eyes dispensed with 8.6-mm lenses was 43.88 D and 45.56 D for eyes dispensed in the 8.4-mm lenses (p < 0.001). Conclusions. A clinically useful criterion showing the need for 8.4-mm lenses was steep K of ≥45.50 D; 77% of these eyes required the steeper lens for good comfort and fit. Subjective discomfort with 8.6-mm lenses was also a useful signal for the need of a steeper lens; mean comfort scores for those subjects rose from 6.33 with 8.6-mm lenses to 9.44 with the 8.4-mm lenses for eyes requiring the steeper lens (p < 0.001).

Fieguth,P., Simpson,T. Automated measurement of bulbar redness. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science 2002;43,2:340-347. [ Show Abstract ]

PURPOSE. To examine the relationship between physical image characteristics and the clinical grading of images of conjunctival redness and to develop an accurate and efficient predictor of clinical redness from the measurements of these images. METHODS. Seventy-two clinicians graded the appearance of 30 images of redness on a 100-point sliding scale with three referent images (at 25, 50, and 75 points) through a World Wide Web-based survey. Using software developed in a commercial computer program, each image was quantified in two ways: by the presence of blood vessel edges, based on the Canny edge-detection algorithm, and by a measure of overall redness, quantified by the relative magnitude of the redness component of each red-green-blue (RGB) pixel. Linear and nonlinear regressors and a Bayesian estimator were used to optimally combine the image characteristics to predict the clinical grades. RESULTS. The clinical judgments of the redness images were highly variable: The average grade range for each image was approximately 55 points, more than half the extent of the entire scale. The median clinical grade was chosen as the most reliable measure of "truth." The median grade was predicted by a weighted linear combination of the edgeness and redness features of each image. The strength of the predicted association was r = 0.976, exceeding the strength of association of all but one of the 72 individual clinicians. CONCLUSIONS. Clinical grading of redness images is highly variable. Despite this human variability, easily implemented image-analysis and statistical procedures were able to reliably predict median clinical grades of conjunctival redness.

Fonn,D., MacDonald,K. E., Richter,D., Pritchard,N. The ocular response to extended wear of a high Dk silicone hydrogel contact lens. Clinical and Experimental Optometry 2002;85,3:176-182. [ Show Abstract ]

Purpose: A four-month extended wear clinical trial was conducted to compare the ocular effects of a high Dk Balafilcon A silicone hydrogel lens and a low Dk HEMA 38.6 per cent H2Osoft lens. Method: Twenty-four subjects who were adapted to daily wear of soft lenses wore a high Dk lens in one eye and a low Dk HEMA lens in the other eye for four months on an extended wear basis after one week of daily wear. Thirteen progress evaluations were conducted using standard clinical procedures. Results: Eighteen subjects (75 per cent) completed the study. The high Dk lens induced significantly less bulbar and limbal injection and corneal vascularisation than the low Dk HEMA lens (p < 0.05). Epithelial microcysts were observed only in the eyes wearing the low Dk lens. A significant increase in myopia was found in the eyes wearing the low Dk HEMA lens (mean = 0.50 D, p < 0.01) compared to the insignificant myopic increase of 0.06 D in the eyes wearing the high Dk lens. Three subjects developed small infiltrates in the high Dk lens wearing eyes and significantly more post-lens debris was observed under the high Dk lens. Six subjects developed papillary conjunctivitis in the eye wearing silicone hydrogel lenses but only two of those were discontinued from the study. Conclusion: No hypoxia-related effects were observed with extended wear of the high Dk Balafilcon A silicone hydrogel lens.

Jones,L., Macdougall,N., Sorbara,L. G. Asymptomatic corneal staining associated with the use of balafilcon silicone-hydrogel contact lenses disinfected with a polyaminopropyl biguanide-preserved care regimen. Optometry and Vision Science 2002;79,12:753-761. [ Show Abstract ]

PURPOSE: To compare subjective symptoms and signs in a group of individuals who wear silicone-hydrogel lenses on a daily wear basis while they sequentially used two differing care regimens. METHODS: Fifty adapted soft-lens wearers were fitted with a silicone-hydrogel lens material (PureVision, Bausch & Lomb). The lenses were worn on a daily wear basis for two consecutive 1-month periods, during which the subjects used either a Polyquad (polyquaternium-1) -based system or a polyaminopropyl biguanide (PHMB) -based system, using a double-masked, randomized, crossover experimental design. RESULTS: Significant levels of relatively asymptomatic corneal staining were observed when subjects used the PHMB-based system, with 37% of subjects demonstrating a level of staining consistent with a classical solution-based toxicity reaction. Only 2% of the subjects exhibited such staining when using the Polyquad-based system. These results were significantly different (p < 0.001). Significant symptoms were not correlated with the degree of staining, with no differences in lens comfort or overall preference being reported between the regimens (p = NS). The only statistically significant difference in symptoms related to minor differences in stinging after lens insertion being reported, with the Polyquad-based system demonstrating less stinging (p < 0.008). CONCLUSIONS: Practitioners who fit silicone-hydrogel contact lenses on a daily wear basis should be wary of the potential for certain PHMB-containing multipurpose care systems to invoke corneal staining. Switching to non-PHMB based regimens will eliminate this complication in most instances.

Jones,L., May,C., Nazar,L., Simpson,T. In vitro evaluation of the dehydration characteristics of silicone hydrogel and conventional hydrogel contact lens materials. Contact Lens and Anterior Eye 2002;25,3:147-156. [ Show Abstract ]

Purpose: This study investigated the in vitro dehydration performance of silicone hydrogel and conventional hydrogel contact lens materials. Methods: In vitro dehydration was assessed using a gravimetric method. The mass loss over time of Focus Night&Day, PureVision, Optima, Acuvue and Proclear Compatibles was measured as the ambient temperature increased from room temperature to 34°C under varying airflow and humidity conditions. Results: Dehydration data demonstrated a typical ogival form. The results were best fitted with a double exponential, non-linear regression model, which accounted for at least 99% of the variance. Regardless of material, increased airflow had a greater impact on dehydration rate than increased humidity (P < 0.05). Relative dehydration amounts were strongly correlated with initial water content (r2 = 0.92), with higher water content materials dehydrating to a greater extent. Conclusions: In vitro dehydration studies of conventional and novel silicone-containing hydrogel materials indicated that evaporation rates from materials are predominantly water content related, with only subtle differences between materials of similar water contents being seen. Environmental conditions have a significant impact on in vitro dehydration, with increased airflow having a greater impact than reduced humidity on increasing dehydration rates. In vitro dehydration is closely related to bulk water diffusion rates and, as a result of their low water content, silicone-containing hydrogel materials exhibit low levels of dehydration compared with high water content hydrogel contact lens materials. Further, in vivo studies are necessary to see if the in vitro dehydration behaviour of silicone hydrogel materials is predictive of in-eye performance. © 2002 British Contact Lens Association. Published by Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.

Mann,A. M., Jones,L. W., Tighe,B. J. The application of counter immunoelectrophoresis (CIE) in ocular protein studies. Part I: Time dependent deposition patterns of immunoregulatory proteins on anionic hydrogel contact lenses. Contact Lens and Anterior Eye 2002;25,2:73-80. [ Show Abstract ]

This paper focuses on the effects of wear regime on the deposition pattern of important immunoregulatory proteins on FDA Group IV etafilcon-A lenses. Specifically, the aim was to assess the extent to which the daily disposable wear modality produces a different deposition of proteins from the conventional daily wear regime which is coupled with cleaning and disinfection. Counter immunoelectrophoresis (CIE) was employed to detect individual proteins in lens extracts from individual patients and focused on the analysis of five proteins, IgA, IgG, lactoferrin, albumin and kininogen. Deposition was monitored as a function of time; significantly lower deposition was detected on the daily disposable lenses. cr 2002 British Contact Lens Association. Published by Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.

Pritchard,N., Young,G., Coleman,S., Hunt,C. Subjective and objective measures of corneal staining related to multipurpose care systems. Contact Lens and Anterior Eye 2002;363-9. [ Show Abstract ]

An objective, digital-imaging method of measuring corneal staining was evaluated in 24 subjects wearing soft contact lenses. The method was used to compare the clinical performance of common multipurpose care systems (MPS) for soft contact lens care. Subjects used three different MPS, one containing polyquaternium-1 (PQ) and two containing polyhexanide (PX1 and PX2), for 2 weeks in a randomised, single-masked (investigator) crossover study. Corneal staining induced with the three MPS was analysed using an image-processing program (ImageTool, UTHSCSA Version 2, University of Texas, USA). Conjunctival hyperaemia and papillae were also evaluated. The intraclass correlation coefficient was similar with image analysis to that of investigator grading (0.876, 0.879, respectively). Significant differences in staining response were detected using the objective method. There was significantly less staining area with polyquaternium-1 (PQ) than polyhexanide (PQ: 0.12 mm2, PX2:0.91 mm2). Inferior palpebral papillae were significantly greater with PX2 than with PQ (1.0, 0.7 (0-4), respectively). The technique was shown to be an effective method of evaluating different corneal staining responses. Bilateral corneal staining in three or more quadrants is useful in the diagnosis of MPS-related staining. © 2003 British Contact Lens Association. Published by Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.

Wang,J., Fonn,D., Simpson,T. L., Jones,L. Relation between optical coherence tomography and optical pachymetry measurements of corneal swelling induced by hypoxia. American Journal of Ophthalmology 2002;134,1:93-98. [ Show Abstract ]

PURPOSE: To determine the relation between optical coherence tomography (OCT) and optical pachymetry (OP) measurements of corneal swelling induced by hypoxia. DESIGN: Experimental study. METHODS: One randomly selected eye of 20 noncontact lens wearers (10 males and 10 females, age 35.6 ± 9.6 years) was patched during 3 hours of soft contact lens (SCL) wear while the contralateral eye acted as control. Central corneal thickness of both eyes was measured before and after SCL wear using OCT and OP in randomized order. RESULTS: Baseline central corneal thickness was 523.6 ± 33.0 μm (mean ± standard deviation [SD]) measured with OCT and 490.6 ± 25.5 μm with OP. Immediately after contact lens removal, corneal thickness measured with OCT increased by 13.8 ± 2.3% compared with 12.1 ± 1.8% (paired t test: P < .001) measured with OP. Thereafter, corneal thickness decreased at the rate of 5.6% per hour for OCT and 5.4% per hour for OP. The difference in thickness between instruments before lens insertion, which was 33 μm compared with the difference after lens removal (edematous cornea), which ranged from 46 to 41 μm. The difference between instruments decreased during the corneal deswelling period after lens removal. The correlation coefficient between OCT and OP was 0.914 before lens insertion and 0.932 after lens removal. CONCLUSION: This study has demonstrated the difference of corneal thickness measured with OCT and OP. Although both instruments are correlated highly in all conditions tested, OCT may overestimate corneal thickness in normal and edematous corneas. © 2002 by Elsevier Science Inc. All rights reserved.

Wang,J., Fonn,D., Simpson,T. L., Jones,L. The measurement of corneal epithelial thickness in response to hypoxia using optical coherence tomography. American Journal of Ophthalmology 2002;133,3:315-319. [ Show Abstract ]

PURPOSE: To determine if corneal epithelial thickness increases in association with corneal edema induced by wearing soft contact lenses during eye closure. DESIGN: Experimental study. METHODS: One eye (randomly selected) of twenty noncontact lens wearers (10 males and 10 females, age 35.6 ± 9.6 years) was patched during 3 hours of soft contact lens (SCL) wear and the contralateral eye acted as a control. Corneal and epithelial thickness of both eyes was measured before and after SCL wear using optical coherence tomography (OCT). RESULTS: Immediately after contact lens removal, total corneal thickness was increased significantly by 13.8 ± 2.3% (mean ± SD) compared with baseline (P .05, paired t test). Immediately after contact lens removal, corneal epithelial thickness was increased by 1.7 ± 4.8%, but this change was not statistically significant (P > .05, paired t test). Following contact lens removal, epithelial thickness changed significantly (Repeated measure analysis of variance [Re-ANOVA]: F(7,133) = 4.91, pH-F < 0.001) over the next 100 minutes with thinning recorded at 60, 80, and 100 minutes (P < .05, paired t test). There was no significant change over time in epithelial thickness of the control eyes (Re-ANOVA: F(4, 76) = 0.91, pH-F = 0.464). CONCLUSION: OCT demonstrated that corneal epithelial thickness does not increase in response to hypoxia from SCL wear and eye closure, in contrast to a significant increase in total corneal thickness. © 2002 by Elsevier Science Inc. All rights reserved.

Young,G., Veys,J., Pritchard,N., Coleman,S. A multi-centre study of lapsed contact lens wearers. Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics 2002;22,6:516-527. [ Show Abstract ]

Purpose: Discontinuation from contact lens wear has been identified as a contributing factor in the lack of growth of contact lens use in Europe. The purpose of this study was to determine the proportion of lapsed contact lens wearers that can be refitted successfully with contact lenses and to evaluate the reasons for discontinuation from contact lens wear. Methods: This was a multi-site clinical study involving 15 UK investigators and 236 lapsed contact lens wearers who had previously tried contact lenses and discontinued. The reasons for discontinuation were assessed by subjects, who were then refitted with contact lenses. Investigators subsequently evaluated factors associated with their initial discontinuation. Short-term success was defined as the successful completion of 1 month of contact lens wear with absence of complications that would prevent further wear. Subjects were interviewed by telephone 6 months after being refitted to determine whether they were still wearing contact lenses. Those who were not wearing lenses were questioned about the reasons for discontinuation and their likelihood of resuming lens wear. Results: A majority of subjects (51%) cited discomfort as the principal reason for having previously given up contact lens wear. Problems with vision were the second most common reason (13%), either with reading (6%) or general vision (7%). The most common type of discomfort was dryness (40%). In almost all cases (97%), the investigator's assessment of the reasons for discontinuation agreed with the subject's own assessment but investigators also cited product-related and practitioner-related factors as contributing to previous failure. The short-term success rate for refitting lapsed wearers was found to be 77% (CI: 70-82%). The highest short-term success rates were for 2-weekly/monthly soft spherical lenses (91%) and daily disposable lenses (89%). Lower success rates were found for soft toric (69%) and soft bifocal (53%) lenses. At the 6-month stage, 73% of those who continued in lenses after the 1-month visit were still wearing contact lenses and a further 18% indicated that they were either 'very likely' or 'likely' to resume lens wear. Conclusions: A high proportion of lapsed contact lens wearers can be successfully refitted with contact lenses. The prime reason for previous discontinuation from contact lenses is discomfort and, in particular, dryness-related discomfort. In many cases, previous contact lens failure is product or practitioner-related rather than because of patient-specific problems. Once refitted with contact lenses, lapsed wearers cite vision problems rather than discomfort as the most common reason for discontinuing. This finding suggests that recent advances in contact lens material, design, replacement frequencies and care systems have improved the prospects for avoiding lens-related discomfort and for continuing contact lens wear. © 2002 The College of Optometrists.